Double-Feature Review: MURDER IN A SMALL TOWN/THE LADY IN QUESTION (1999)

After a string of hits in the 1970s and 1980s, a few of which he either wrote, co-wrote, or directed, Gene Wilder’s fame started to slow down, with a number of critical and box-office disappointments. After a stint on network TV with his own sitcom, Something Wilder (1994-95), and a battle with cancer, which he eventually won, Wilder was content to ease into semi-retirement, appearing in small plays, and doing a number of cameos in TV movies.

Which brings me to Murder in A Small Town and The Lady in Question, two TV movies that aired on A&E in 1999. These two delightful mysteries, co-written and starring Wilder and directed by Joyce Chopra, and set in 1930s Connecticut, allow Wilder to showcase his talents as an actor and writer, and were the last time he ever took a starring role.

Murder in A Small Town, the better of the two features, introduces Wilder as Larry “Cash” Carter, a former actor now working as a director in a local theater, who gets entangled in a complex mystery involving the death of a local millionaire who has a long list of enemies. Wilder, and his charming supporting cast (which includes Cherry Jones and Mike Starr), glide through the film with an easy, likable panache, and the whole affair comes off as classy, stylish, and wonderfully entertaining for fans of classic mysteries.

The second feature, The Lady in Question, is more problematic, but still enjoyable, with its serpentine plot involving Nazis and espionage, large cast, and unexpected denouement. But it comes off as less polished and slightly incoherent, with a meandering script, and surprisingly less focus on Wilder’s character, who somewhat takes a backseat throughout most of the film.

The tone is also less consistent and more self-indulgent. But still, this is a classy piece of work, and a great choice for a winter night.

Both films showcase Wilder at his most versatile and laid-back, and are a must watch for his fans and fans of classic mysteries.

Text © Ahmed Khalifa. 2022.

Video Version:

 

Ahmed Khalifa is a filmmaker and novelist. He is the writer/director of several short films and a feature, which was released on Netflix, and the author of a number of novels and short stories, including the YA horror novel, Beware The Stranger, available on Amazon. Find him on Twitter @AFKhalifa and on Facebook @Dark.Fantastic.AK·Writer